Aerial view of curved resort pool with umbrellas, beach, and palm trees by ocean

Tropical resort pool with palm trees and turquoise water at sunset

Aerial view of Mickey Mouse-shaped pool complex with loungers, palm trees, and beachfront setting

Sandy beach with palm trees leaning over sand, lounge chairs, calm water, and pier pilings

Aerial view of beachfront resort with turquoise pool, palm trees, sandy beach, and waterfront docks

Family swimming in resort pool with palm trees, white umbrellas, and tropical setting

Aerial view of kidney-shaped pool surrounded by beach, umbrellas, and palm trees by ocean

7 photos, view gallery

Amara Cay Resort

Name: Amara Cay Resort
Address: 80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, Florida, 3802, US
Price range: Starting at $20
Rating: 4.7

4.7 (134)

Islamorada, Florida

4 star propertyTrendy

Create unforgettable moments at this beachfront escape, where the vibe is active, social, and effortlessly relaxed. Spend the day your way, float in the zero‑entry ocean view pool, sway in a hammock on the private beach, challenge friends to beach games, or explore the water by paddleboard and kayak. When you’re ready to unwind, sip your favorite island cocktails from the poolside Tiki Bar.

Select a date

Experiences

Day Pass

Float in the ocean view pool, paddle the Keys, and play beach games on a private stretch of sand.

Complimentary Gift

$75

Cabana

Claim a shaded poolside cabana with sofa seating, two sun loungers, and privacy curtains for four.

Complimentary Gift

$275

Only 1 left

4 guests

Day Room

Extend your beach day with a private room retreat, perfect for a midday nap or shower between pool sessions.

$250

Unavailable on 8/1

2 guests

Launch & Lounge Day Pass

Launch your jet ski to Alligator Reef Lighthouse, then unwind poolside at the Tiki Bar, for two.

$200

Unavailable on 8/1

2 guests

Beachside Yoga

Move through a rejuvenating flow beneath the Lighthouse Tiki, ocean breeze and turquoise views included.

$20

Unavailable on 8/1

Water Aerobics

Splash into a low-impact cardio and toning class led by certified instructor Nelly Paredes in the pool.

$20

Unavailable on 8/1

Property details

Location

80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036-3802

Amenities

Outdoor Pool

Beach Access

Free Parking

Towels

Luggage Storage

Pool

Food Service

Drink Service

Pool & Beach

Sunrise - sunset

Poolside Food & Drink Service

Daily 11:30am - 11:00pm

Happy Hour

Daily: 4:00pm - 6:00pm

Tiki Bar

Daily 11:30 am - 11 pm

Food service daily from 11:30 am - 10 pm

Live Music at the Tiki Bar

Thursday - Saturday 6:00pm - 9:00pm

Reelcatch Restaurant

Breakfast

Daily 7:00am - 11:00am

Dinner

Daily 5:00pm - 10:00pm

Good to know

What happens when I get there?

Check in at the front desk with your confirmation and a photo ID — the same way any hotel guest would. The hotel knows you’re coming.

What’s included in the price listed?

Your booking covers everything listed on the experience page — no hidden fees. Some properties offer food, drinks, or extras you can add on once you're there, but nothing is required unless noted.

Can I cancel if my plans change?

Yes, most bookings can be canceled for a full refund. Cancellation windows and refund eligibility details are found on the experience page. Read our full cancellation policy.

Amara Cay Resort